Planning a visit to Alcoa or Maryville, Tennessee? Or perhaps you’re a local looking to discover your next favorite meal? This charming region nestled at the foothills of the Great Smoky Mountains offers a surprisingly diverse and delicious culinary scene. From authentic Southern BBQ to international delights and upscale dining, Alcoa and Maryville have something to tantalize every taste bud.
To make your dining decisions easy, here’s a quick list of the top 10 must-try restaurants:
-
The Blackhorse Brewery (Maryville location)
-
Cracker Barrel Old Country Store (Alcoa location)
Now, let’s dive deeper into what makes each of these establishments a culinary gem!
Savoring the Local Flavors: A Restaurant Deep Dive
1. Hatcher’s On Point BBQ Authentic Southern BBQ, Alcoa, TN
You can’t come to East Tennessee without experiencing true Southern barbecue, and Hatcher’s On Point BBQ delivers exactly that. Renowned for its slow-smoked meats and classic sides, Hatcher’s embodies the heart of regional comfort food. Reviewers consistently praise their tender pulled pork and brisket, with many citing the “smoky flavor that just can’t be beat.” While some note that popular items can sell out quickly, this only speaks to its immense popularity and quality. Hatcher’s is a true reflection of Tennessee’s rich BBQ tradition, a place where food tells a story of heritage and flavor.
2. Aroma Cafe Eclectic American Cuisine, Maryville, TN
Aroma Cafe offers a refreshing break from the ordinary with its diverse menu and charming atmosphere. Specializing in creative American dishes with international influences, Aroma Cafe is a favorite for those seeking something a bit different. Diners often rave about their unique specials and homemade desserts. One reviewer mentioned, “Always fresh and delicious, Aroma Cafe never disappoints!” While occasional comments suggest the space can get busy, the consensus points to exceptional food quality and friendly service. It’s a testament to Maryville’s growing appreciation for sophisticated yet approachable dining.
3. The Blackhorse Brewery Craft Beer & Gastropub Fare, Maryville, TN
A staple in the Tennessee craft beer scene, The Blackhorse Brewery’s Maryville location brings its popular brews and elevated pub food to the forefront. It’s a place where local culture and modern culinary tastes converge. Expect hearty burgers, inventive appetizers, and delicious entrees designed to pair perfectly with their extensive beer list. Patrons frequently highlight the “great beer selection and surprisingly good food.” A few reviews mention wait times during peak hours, but the vibrant atmosphere and quality offerings keep people coming back. The Blackhorse is more than just a brewery; it’s a community hub reflecting Maryville’s lively social scene.
4. Cracker Barrel Old Country Store Classic Southern Comfort Food & Country Store, Alcoa, TN
While a chain, Cracker Barrel holds a special place in the Southern culinary landscape, and the Alcoa location is a reliable stop for travelers and locals alike seeking classic comfort food. It’s an iconic representation of Southern hospitality and home-style cooking. From breakfast served all day to their famous chicken n’ dumplins, Cracker Barrel offers a taste of tradition. Reviews often laud the “consistent quality and friendly service” that the brand is known for. While some might find it less unique than local establishments, it remains a beloved choice for its comforting familiarity and value, truly embodying a slice of Americana.
5. The Pickled Pig Modern American Gastropub, Maryville, TN
The Pickled Pig has quickly become a local darling, celebrated for its innovative take on classic American dishes and its commitment to fresh, often locally sourced, ingredients. This gastropub offers a sophisticated yet comfortable dining experience. Customers often praise their creative menu items and the inviting ambiance. One reviewer exclaimed, “The Pickled Pig is a true culinary gem in Maryville – everything is phenomenal!” While occasional feedback points to it being on the pricier side, the quality and unique flavors are consistently highlighted as worth the splurge. It represents Maryville’s evolving palate and desire for elevated dining experiences.
6. Amici Authentic Italian Cuisine, Maryville, TN
For a taste of Italy in East Tennessee, Amici stands out. This beloved Italian restaurant is known for its authentic dishes, from pasta to wood-fired pizzas, all crafted with care. The warm, inviting atmosphere makes it perfect for a family dinner or a romantic evening. Reviews frequently commend the “delicious pasta dishes” and the “friendly, attentive staff.” While a few comments suggest busy evenings can impact service speed, the overall sentiment is overwhelmingly positive regarding the quality and authenticity of the food. Amici adds an international flavor to Maryville’s dining scene, showcasing its diverse appeal.
7. La Lupita Mexican Restaurant Vibrant Mexican Cuisine, Alcoa, TN
La Lupita brings the lively flavors of Mexico to Alcoa with its extensive menu of traditional dishes. It’s a go-to spot for fresh salsa, sizzling fajitas, and generously portioned platters. The festive atmosphere and quick service are often highlighted by patrons. One happy diner shared, “Best Mexican food in the area, hands down!” While large crowds can sometimes lead to a bustling environment, the vibrant food and strong margaritas make it a consistent favorite. La Lupita reflects Alcoa’s appreciation for bold, flavorful, and family-friendly dining options.
8. Anaba Japanese Cuisine Fresh Sushi & Japanese Delicacies, Maryville, TN
Anaba Japanese Cuisine offers a refined dining experience with a focus on fresh sushi, sashimi, and classic Japanese entrees. It’s a popular choice for those seeking elegant flavors and artfully presented dishes. Reviewers often praise the “freshness of the sushi” and the “beautiful presentation.” While some find the prices slightly higher, they generally agree the quality justifies the cost. Anaba represents Maryville’s increasing sophistication and its embrace of diverse international cuisines, providing a tranquil escape with exceptional food.
9. The Walnut Kitchen Upscale Southern-Inspired Dining, Maryville, TN
For a truly memorable and upscale dining experience, The Walnut Kitchen is Maryville’s premier destination. This restaurant prides itself on its farm-to-table approach, crafting modern American dishes with a distinct Southern influence, often featuring locally sourced ingredients. The elegant ambiance and impeccable service are frequently lauded. Patrons describe their meals as “culinary masterpieces” and the experience as “fine dining at its best.” While it is undoubtedly a higher-end option, the consistent five-star reviews affirm its status as a top-tier establishment. The Walnut Kitchen perfectly encapsulates the refined side of East Tennessee’s culinary aspirations.
10. The Shed Smokehouse and Juke Joint BBQ, Live Music & Unique Atmosphere, Maryville, TN
More than just a restaurant, The Shed Smokehouse and Juke Joint is an institution. Located at Smoky Mountain Harley-Davidson, it’s famous for its delicious barbecue, cold drinks, and, most notably, its incredible live music venue. It’s where food and entertainment blend seamlessly into a quintessential East Tennessee experience. Reviewers often celebrate the “amazing atmosphere and great live bands,” alongside the “solid BBQ.” While service can be stretched during large concert events, the overall experience of great food combined with top-notch entertainment makes it a unique and unforgettable spot. The Shed truly embodies the lively, hospitable, and music-loving spirit of Maryville.
Discover Your Next Favorite Meal
Whether you’re craving classic Southern comfort, exotic international flavors, or a sophisticated culinary adventure, Alcoa and Maryville, TN, offer an incredible array of dining options. These ten establishments represent the best of what the region has to offer, each contributing to the rich tapestry of East Tennessee’s vibrant food scene. So, next time you’re in the area, be sure to explore these fantastic restaurants and taste the local culture for yourself!